Medical Diagnoses in The Knick: A Comprehensive Review of Medical Conditions in Season 1
- 4 days ago
- 6 min read
Season 1 of The Knick transports viewers to the raw, unfiltered world of 1900s medicine at the Knickerbocker Hospital. The series highlights the brutal reality of a time when surgical innovation was often a matter of trial and error, and aseptic technique was still in its infancy. From Dr. Thackery's battle with addiction to the hunt for Typhoid Mary, the season explores the dawn of modern surgery amidst a backdrop of social inequality and public health crises.
Below is a comprehensive review of the specific medical diagnoses and treatments featured throughout Season 1.
Episode 1
Lacerated Bowel and Secondary Septicemia
Mr. Sebastiano Gentile suffered a fractured pelvis after being hit by a streetcar. Bone fragments caused four puncture wounds in his bowel. Progression: Post-operatively, he developed septicemia (blood poisoning) due to failed catgut sutures leaking bowel contents. Symptoms included high fever and limb discoloration. Treatment: Because bronchitis made ether anesthesia deadly, Dr. Thackery performed a pioneering spinal anesthesia using cocaine. He resected 12 inches of intestine using a specialized metal clamping device.
Placenta Previa
Mrs. Warren presented with placenta previa, where the placenta blocks the cervix. A sudden hemorrhage forced an emergency C-section. Surgical Approach: Dr. Christiansen and Dr. Thackery attempted a high-speed extraction (aiming for 100 seconds) to minimize blood loss. Outcome: The procedure failed; the fetus was trapped in the umbilical cord, and the mother died from hemorrhage. This marked the twelfth consecutive failure for Dr. Christiansen.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Jaundice: Liver dysfunction presenting as yellow skin and blood in urine.
Bronchitis: Respiratory inflammation complicating anesthesia.
Tuberculosis: Infectious disease causing lung congestion and clubbing.
Cleft Lip: Congenital condition requiring reconstruction.
Breech Presentation: Fetus positioned feet-first.
Episode 2
Aortic Aneurysm
Mr. Gatchell and Mr. Olynyk. Two patients presented with rapidly growing aortic aneurysms. Mr. Gatchell's was eroding his ribs, while Mr. Olynyk's aorta had "lost all form." Treatment: Dr. Thackery attempted an aneurysmorrhaphy and Hunter’s ligation on Mr. Olynyk. The arterial tissue was too friable ("shredding like paper") to hold sutures, and the patient died. Future Plan: The team considered an experimental galvanic procedure (using electricity) for Mr. Gatchell.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Syphilis: Chronic infection causing systemic damage.
Typhoid Fever: Systemic illness causing high fever.
Elephantiasis: Massive enlargement of limbs due to lymphatic obstruction.
Gigantism: Overproduction of growth hormone.
Episode 3
Syphilis and Nasal Reconstruction
Mrs. Abby Alford suffered from advanced syphilis, which had destroyed her nasal cartilage and bone. Treatment: Dr. Thackery performed a skin graft from her arm. The arm was harnessed to her face for weeks to establish blood supply before the flap was shaped into a new nose.
Typhoid Fever and Intestinal Perforation
Cora, a wealthy socialite, contracted typhoid fever. Complication: The disease caused intestinal perforation. Treatment: Dr. Thackery performed emergency surgery to stitch the perforated gut to the peritoneum, saving her life despite the high risk.
Inguinal Hernia
Herman "Herm" Cockrell. A laborer suffered a hernia from physical work. Treatment: Dr. Edwards performed an illicit repair in the basement using a three-layer technique. However, the patient returned to work too soon, tore the repair, and died from internal hemorrhaging.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Dental Infection: Inflammation requiring extraction.
Infarction: Tissue death from obstructed blood supply.
Episode 4
Aortic Aneurysm (Galvanic Procedure)
Mr. Gatchell's descending aorta aneurysm reached a critical state. Treatment: Surgeons inserted a silver-copper alloy wire into the aneurysm and applied electricity (galvanic procedure). This induced clotting to reinforce the arterial wall, successfully restoring his pulse.
Typhoid Fever Outbreak
Daniel and Cora Hemming. Inspector Speight and Cornelia Robertson traced the outbreak to the Hemming household. Source: Epidemiological investigation pinpointed unboiled ice cream (Peach Melba) as the medium, leading the hunt for the carrier.
Meningitis
Rat-Baiter. A patient bitten by rats presented with a stiff neck and seizures. Diagnosis: Confirmed meningitis via Kernig’s signs. Treatment: Application of Cantharidin (Spanish fly) to blister the skin as a counterirritant, along with ice bladders.
Uterine Perforation
Unnamed Woman. A patient arrived with massive hemorrhage from a self-induced abortion. Diagnosis: Uterine perforation. Treatment: Despite clamps and experimental manual heart massage, the patient died.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Appendicitis: Inflammation of the appendix.
Pneumonia: Acute respiratory infection.
Episode 5
Irreducible Indirect Inguinal Hernia
Mr. Mendieta. A cigar roller presented with a hernia that could not be manually reduced. Treatment: Dr. Edwards used silver wire sutures instead of silk to reinforce the repair, a successful innovation for durable closure.
Placenta Previa (Fatal)
Mrs. Lefkowitz. An extreme case of placenta previa with prolonged labor. Treatment: Dr. Thackery performed a C-section in a record 72 seconds. Despite the speed, the patient died due to blood loss.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Bullet Wound: Trauma causing bone fracture and necrosis.
Metacarpal Fractures: Hand bone breaks identified by X-ray.
Renal Cyst: Fluid sac causing back pain.
Episode 6
Placenta Previa (Surgical Solution)
Unnamed Woman. Thackery and Chickering invented the "Basketball Bladder Bullet". Treatment: An inflatable bladder was inserted into the uterus to tamponade the bleeding from the inside, buying time for surgical repair. The mother and baby survived.
Asymptomatic Typhoid Fever (Typhoid Mary)
Mary Mallon was identified as the link between multiple wealthy households with typhoid outbreaks. Diagnosis: She was the first identified asymptomatic carrier. Action: Mallon was apprehended for testing and forced quarantine.
Meningitis / Brain Swelling
Lillian Gallinger. An infant presented with high fever and a protruding fontanel. Treatment: Dr. Gallinger attempted a venesection (bleeding) to reduce pressure, but the infant died.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Rheumatism: Chronic joint inflammation.
Sciatica: Nerve pain.
Cataracts: Clouding of the lens.
Melancholia: Severe depression.
Episode 7
Acute Appendicitis ("The Thackery Point")
Unnamed Attorney. A healthy man struck by acute abdominal pain. Diagnosis: Appendicitis. Innovation: Thackery used a new diagnostic landmark, "The Thackery Point," to accurately locate the appendix for removal.
Traumatic Internal Hemorrhage
Officer Phinny Sears. A stabbing victim arrived with critical internal bleeding. Diagnosis: The liver was "sliced," and the hepatic artery severed. Treatment: Despite using the Edwards suction machine to clear the field, the patient died before repairs could hold.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Hematemesis: Vomiting blood.
Ischemia: Restricted blood flow to organs.
Leprosy: Contagious disease mentioned in outbreak context.
Episode 8
Actinomycosis ("Ray Fungus")
Mr. Tuttle. A patient developed a hard jaw mass after dental work. Diagnosis: Actinomycosis, a fungal-like bacterial infection. Treatment: Potassium iodide failed. Thackery attempted surgical curettage but abandoned it due to drug withdrawal tremors.
Asymptomatic Typhoid Carrier
Mary Mallon. Stool samples confirmed a pure culture of bacillus typhi. Outcome: Despite medical proof, a judge released her. She resumed cooking under an alias.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Cocaine Withdrawal: Tremors and headaches affecting surgical performance.
Episode 9
Cocaine and Opioid Dependence
Dr. John Thackery’s addiction escalated to cocaine madness due to a shortage. Symptoms: Tactile hallucinations ("bedbugs"), paranoia, and criminal behavior to secure drugs. Treatment: Self-medication with opium and theft.
Capsulocretaceous Cataracts
Mr. Oates. Calcified cataracts required removal. Treatment: Surgery planned using Holocaine due to cocaine shortage.
Helminthic Ingestion (Tapeworm)
Miss Gibson. A patient ingested a tapeworm for weight loss. Treatment: Dr. Edwards prescribed castor oil to purge the parasite.
Maternal Mental Health ("Brain Fever")
Eleanor Gallinger exhibited delusional behavior after her daughter's death, including putting an infant in an ice bath. Diagnosis: Severe psychological distress termed "brain fever."
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Dilation and Curettage: Surgical procedure for pregnancy termination.
Morphine Dependence: Common addiction among the poor.
Episode 10
Blood Type Incompatibility
Young Female. Thackery investigated why transfusions failed. Theory: He incorrectly hypothesized blood types were based on cell size. Outcome: The transfusion failed due to agglutinating antibodies, resulting in the patient's death.
Cocaine Addiction
Dr. John Thackery injected up to 12 grams daily. Treatment: He was admitted to Cromartie Hospital. The "cure" introduced was Heroin (diacetylmorphine) from Bayer.
Mental Disorders via Focal Infection
Eleanor Gallinger. Dr. Cotton believed mental illness stemmed from physical infection. Treatment: All of Eleanor's teeth were extracted. Future plans included removing tonsils and colon.
Splenic Anemia
32-Year-Old Male. Identified by green skin coloration. Treatment: Thackery performed a breakthrough splenectomy.
Other Medical Diagnoses and Conditions Discussed
Chlorosis: Anemia resistant to arsenic treatment.
Brain Tumor: Mass treated by trephining.
Pulmonary Abscess: Pus collection in lung.
🔖 Key Takeaways
🗝️ Surgical Innovation: The season highlighted the invention of tools and techniques still relevant or foundational today, such as spinal anesthesia, silver wire sutures, and the "Thackery Point" for appendicitis.
🗝️ Public Health: The hunt for Typhoid Mary underscored the emerging field of epidemiology and the struggle to understand asymptomatic carriers.
🗝️ Medical Ethics: From illicit hernia repairs to the brutal "focal infection" theory for mental illness, the show explored the unregulated and often cruel nature of early medicine.
🗝️ Addiction: Dr. Thackery's descent into cocaine madness provided a stark look at the lack of understanding regarding substance abuse and the dangerous "cures" of the time (Heroin).
🗝️ Obstetrics: The high mortality rate of placenta previa drove a season-long arc to develop a life-saving balloon tamponade technique.
Keywords: Medical Diagnoses The Knick Season 1
Medical Diagnoses The Knick Season 1
Comments