Rediscovering Joseph Merrick: The True Story of The Elephant Man, Frederick Treves and His Enduring Legacy
- 1 day ago
- 7 min read
The story of Joseph Merrick, famously known as The Elephant Man, has become one of the most recognizable and tragic narratives of the Victorian era, yet the man himself, and the truth of his life, were nearly forgotten until relatively recently. Merrick was a young man born in 1862 who, from the age of five, began developing severe and progressive physical deformities, which today are most commonly believed to be an extreme case of Proteus syndrome. This rare genetic condition causes the body's cells to divide uncontrollably, resulting in huge, ugly growths of bone and flesh that both frightened and thrilled the public. However, beyond the spectacle of his appearance, the real Joseph Merrick was an individual who faced unimaginable cruelty with sincere kindness and grace. His journey from a sideshow curiosity to a celebrated figure in the London Hospital—guided by the complex interest of surgeon Frederick Treves—provides a powerful meditation on dignity, acceptance, and the enduring nature of human compassion. The resurgence of his narrative through the 1970s play, subsequent books, and the 1980 film ensures that the humanity of Joseph Merrick is no longer obscured by his physical appearance.
The Man Behind the Myth: Joseph Merrick's Early Life and Affliction
Born perfectly healthy in Leicester, England, on August 5, 1862, Joseph Merrick’s life changed dramatically around the age of five when his deformities began to manifest. In the absence of medical understanding, his mother, Mary, came to believe that the condition was caused by her being knocked down by an elephant at a fair during her pregnancy—an incident that some sources suggest may have involved an elephant escaping from a local circus in 1862.
A major misconception perpetuated by popular retellings stems from Dr. Frederick Treves himself, who mistakenly referred to the man as "John Merrick" in his memoirs, The Elephant Man and Other Reminiscences. This error was picked up by Bernard Pomerance for his acclaimed 1977 play, The Elephant Man. Despite the subsequent cruelty and stares he endured from strangers, Joseph Merrick had a loving and close relationship with his mother, whose death from pneumonia when he was 11 was described by him as "the greatest misfortune of my life". His life deteriorated sharply after his father remarried, prompting him to flee home.
The Complex Reality of the Sideshow Circuit
By the Victorian era, showmen frequently made money exhibiting human curiosities for public entertainment, and for people with severe disabilities, freak shows often offered the only viable means of earning income. Facing financial hardship and homelessness, Joseph Merrick made the difficult decision to monetize his deformities, choosing to exhibit himself in public to survive. In 1884, he began touring with local proprietor Sam Torr, billed as "half a man, half an elephant". He later switched management to Tom Norman, who displayed him in a shop in East London, across the road from the London Hospital.
While films and the memoirs of Frederick Treves often portray Merrick’s showmen, like the character Bytes, as violently vicious figures who treated him "as if to a dog," historians suggest a more nuanced reality. The sources note that Merrick chose this career path and that his initial showman, Norman, may have even been a decent man with whom Merrick established an equal financial partnership. Merrick displayed "enterprise and gumption," managing to save £50 in 22 months—a substantial sum equivalent to a year's income for a working-class family at the time. The tendency to portray him as a helpless victim, as done by Treves and the 1980 film, perhaps made him more sympathetic but obscured the strength of the real Joseph Merrick. As Peter Ford points out, Merrick actively sought out life on the freak circuit, viewing it as an economic necessity in Victorian Britain.
The Pivotal Encounter with Dr. Frederick Treves
The moment that altered the course of Joseph Merrick’s life occurred in 1884, when young surgeon Frederick Treves ventured away from his work at the London Hospital in Whitechapel to inspect "The Elephant Man" at the nearby shop. Intrigued by the sight, Treves took Merrick back to the hospital for an examination.
Treves' interest was complex. While Merrick was genuinely worthy of academic study, Treves also recognized the potential benefit to his own professional standing. Treves, who later became surgeon to the king and received a knighthood, understood how society worked. Ultimately, however, Treves provided salvation by finding Merrick a permanent, safe space to live in the London Hospital, violating institutional rules to do so.
Following an attempt to continue his exhibition career, which ended disastrously when he was robbed and abandoned by a new manager in Belgium, Merrick was found distressed back in London. The awful scene at Liverpool Street station, where he was besieged by a mob, prompted police to use Treves' visiting card (which Merrick carried) to arrange his return to the London Hospital.
Humanity and Dignity at the London Hospital
Once safely admitted to the care of Frederick Treves, Merrick found peace and belonging, receiving comfortable, specially adapted rooms in the hospital basement that included access to a private courtyard and were free of mirrors. The hospital’s chairman was prompted to publish an appeal in The Times asking for donations to support Merrick’s care, receiving an "overwhelming" public response.
Treves initially feared Merrick was an imbecile, but as The Elephant Man began to communicate, Treves realized he was not only sane but "a gentle, affectionate and lovable creature". This period in the hospital allowed Merrick to finally be seen as a human being, not just a curiosity. He was intellectually bright and particularly enjoyed writing letters. He often closed his correspondence with four poetic lines he wrote himself, followed by an excerpt from Isaac Watts’ poem "False Greatness," which beautifully captured his lifelong desire:
‘Tis true my form is something odd, But blaming me is blaming God; Could I create myself anew, I would not fail in pleasing you.
This time in the hospital also saw Merrick become a minor figure on the London social scene, even receiving a visit from Princess Alexandra in 1887.
The Cultural Resurrection of The Elephant Man
For a time, the story of Joseph Merrick slipped into obscurity, known primarily through Frederick Treves’ memoirs. If Treves had not seen Merrick in that small Whitechapel shop and subsequently written about him, the story may never have survived at all.
However, the late 1970s and early 1980s saw a massive revival. Playwright Bernard Pomerance’s 1977 play The Elephant Man first brought the story to acclaim and a new generation of audiences. In 1980, Peter Ford and Michael Howell co-wrote The True History of the Elephant Man, which became the standard account for the general reader. Soon after, David Lynch’s 1980 film, starring John Hurt, dramatically cemented the story in popular culture, despite taking some liberties with the facts and chronology—such as depicting his return from Belgium after his initial hospital admission.
The combined effect of the play, the book, and the film was powerful, ensuring that long after his death, Joseph Merrick became a lasting icon of the Victorian era. The play, originally seen as a political and social commentary, evolved, partly because of the film, into a highly sought-after "star vehicle" for actors like David Bowie and Bradley Cooper. Notably, the theatrical tradition, established by David Schofield in the original 1977 production, avoids gross make-up or prosthetics to ensure Merrick is not exploited on stage as he was in life.
A Timeless Lesson in Compassion
Tragically, Joseph Merrick’s life was cut short at the age of 27. Due to the immense weight of his head, caused by his continuous bone growth, he was forced to sleep sitting upright to avoid potential complications. On April 11, 1890, he was discovered lying in bed—having seemingly tried to sleep "just like everybody else"—and died. Treves initially attributed the death to asphyxiation, though a later theory suggests his neck dislocated under the head's weight, crushing his spinal column. Following his death and autopsy, Merrick’s skeleton was preserved as a scientific specimen.
Despite the unimaginable hardships he endured, his story remains a powerful testament to the enduring human spirit. The continuous interest, sparked by new productions of the play, keeps the real Joseph Merrick—the kind, intelligent man who simply wished to be accepted—in the public eye. His legacy serves as a timely reminder that dignity and humanity are measured not by physical form, but by the "mind’s the standard of the man".
🔖 Key Takeaways
🗝️ Identity and Condition: The true name of The Elephant Man was Joseph Merrick, not John Merrick (an error introduced by Frederick Treves’ memoirs). He likely suffered from Proteus syndrome, a rare condition causing extreme, asymmetrical growth.
🗝️ Agency vs. Victimhood: Merrick actively chose to enter the freak show circuit as an economic necessity and demonstrated agency, contrary to the common portrayal of him as a completely helpless victim exploited by all.
🗝️ The Treves Relationship: Dr. Frederick Treves’ encounter with Merrick in 1884 was pivotal, leading to Merrick finding a permanent, safe home at the London Hospital, where he flourished socially and intellectually until his death at age 27.
🗝️ Cultural Revival: Merrick’s story was almost lost to history, but the simultaneous success of the 1977 play, The True History of the Elephant Man book, and the 1980 film revived his narrative and cemented him as an enduring icon of Victorian culture.
🗝️ Enduring Message: Merrick's life embodies a plea for acceptance, powerfully articulated in his own poetry, asserting that a person should be measured by their soul and mind, not their appearance.
🌐 External sources
Keywords: The Elephant Man
The Elephant Man
Comments