The Shocking End of Critical: Why the Lennie James Medical Drama Faced Season 2 Cancellation
- 2 days ago
- 5 min read
The world of television thrillers owes a significant debt to writer/director Jed Mercurio, the creative force behind modern British TV successes like the unbearably tense police drama Line Of Duty, which has been running since 2012, and the breakout hit Bodyguard. Mercurio's history in the medical field—having worked as a practicing hospital physician long before his television career took off—also led him to pen medical dramas such as Cardiac Arrest and Bodies. In 2015, he added to this specialized list with the Sky 1 series, Critical, a show centered on a team of medical professionals racing against the clock following catastrophic accidents. Despite being fronted by a great cast, led by Lennie James, and receiving good reviews, Critical was abruptly cancelled after just one 13-part season. This outcome left its star immensely disappointed and sparked discussion about the conflict between critical success and ratings reality, ultimately sealing the fate of the proposed Critical Season 2.
The Genesis of a Groundbreaking Medical Thriller
Critical was designed to stand apart from typical medical shows by stripping away what its lead star called "the fluff and nonsense". The series focused intensely on the actual process of healing the patient through medicine, rather than relying on emotional tropes like "a kind word and a hug". The show revolved around the immediate aftermath of horrible accidents.
The drama was defined by its commitment to realism, including surgery sequences that were frequently described as both realistic and often extremely graphic. Crucially, the series revolved around the "Golden Hour," emphasizing the often-crucial first 60 minutes of treatment following injury, where prompt care is paramount to saving a patient’s life. Due to its relentless pace and high-stakes atmosphere, some described Critical as a medical version of 24.
The ensemble cast included strong talent, with Lennie James—known for his role as Morgan in The Walking Dead and later Fear The Walking Dead—leading the show. Other notable cast members included Irish actress Catherine Walker, Claire Skinner, and Kimberley Nixon.
The Critical Reception and the Ratings Conundrum
The fate of the Lennie James Medical Drama was determined swiftly in 2015 when Sky 1 confirmed the cancellation before a second season could be produced. The primary issue was not quality, but audience reach.
Critical Acclaim vs. Ratings Reality
While Critical received positive reviews and achieved "critical success," it failed to become a major ratings winner. A source reported by Radio Times confirmed the show was a critical success but "didn’t quite get the ratings". Sky 1, the network that aired the show, expressed pride in the series, noting its "acclaim" and "ground-breaking achievements in the production of TV medical drama". Despite this high praise from the network itself, the ratings shortfall ultimately led to the decision to axe the series after just 13 episodes.
The Leading Man’s Fight: Lennie James’s Disappointment
The cancellation decision deeply frustrated Lennie James. He stated that he was "immensely proud" of Critical and would have loved to return for a second season. His comments went beyond mere disappointment, incorporating sharp criticism of how Sky 1 handled the show’s promotion and support.
James contended that the series deserved more than a "one and done" fate and felt the network had failed to adequately promote the series after its initial launch. He observed that Critical "opened in a blaze of publicity – and then there was nothing," suggesting a pattern that Sky should examine. He argued that because the show asked viewers to look at medical drama "in a very different light," it needed more robust support from the network.
A Legacy of Prestige Over Popularity
The reaction from some fans echoed James's sentiments. One commenter noted their disappointment that a "feasible medical series" like Critical ended after one season, contrasting its realistic approach with the long survival of less credible medical shows. James clearly felt that Critical was something that might have "taken Sky by surprise," suggesting that the network might not have understood or appropriately marketed its groundbreaking nature, thus warranting a second chance that was never granted.
The Final Verdict: Why a Revival Seems Bleak
The question of whether the Critical Season 2 could ever come together lingers, but the chances seem increasingly bleak, even years after its original cancellation. While it is not unheard of for a series to be revived on a different network or streaming platform years after its initial cancellation, there has been no indication that Critical is being revisited.
Furthermore, the creative forces behind the show have firmly moved on to other highly successful projects. Jed Mercurio is preoccupied with new seasons of his established hits, Bodyguard and Line Of Duty. Similarly, Lennie James has cemented his role in the post-apocalyptic universe, playing Morgan on Fear The Walking Dead. Over five years after the show finished airing (as of the August 2020 update), the commitments of its creator and lead star make the possibility of assembling a new series remote.
🔖 Key Takeaways
The story of Critical illustrates the harsh intersection where innovative television meets commercial pressures. The brief run of the Lennie James Medical Drama provided several clear lessons:
🗝️ High-Stakes Realism: Critical, created by former physician Jed Mercurio, was distinct for its focus on the "Golden Hour" and realistic, graphic surgery sequences, setting it apart from more traditional, fluffier medical dramas.
🗝️ The Ratings Killer: Despite receiving favorable reviews and praise for its production achievements, the show was canceled after its 13-episode run because it was not a significant ratings winner for Sky 1.
🗝️ The Promotion Critique: Star Lennie James openly criticized the network, Sky 1, for failing to adequately support and promote the series after its initial publicity push. James felt the show deserved a second chance and more support due to its unique approach.
🗝️ Moving On: Any realistic prospect for a Critical Season 2 Cancellation reversal is dim. Both Mercurio and James have high-profile commitments elsewhere, primarily with Bodyguard, Line Of Duty, and Fear The Walking Dead.
The cancellation of Critical highlights that sometimes, even highly praised, groundbreaking, and realistic television—praised even by its network for its accomplishments—cannot survive without achieving widespread commercial success. The show’s rapid demise serves as a compelling example of critical acclaim being insufficient to secure renewal in a competitive market. It was a diamond cut with precision, yet it lacked the immediate shine needed to draw in a large enough audience.
🌐 External sources
Keywords: Critical Season 2 Cancellation
Critical Season 2 Cancellation
Comments